|
|
|
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Corneal Atlas The Role of CorticosteroidsThe first of a four-part series, this article details the
pathophysiology, diagnosis and management of six infectious diseases. by Joseph Sowka, O.D. and Alan Kabat, O.D.,Contributing Editors With copious sensory innervation and an essential role in visual refraction, the cornea and
anterior segment are critical to visual health and function. For us as optometrists, knowledge of these structures—the most therapeutically accessible area of the eye—and their associated disorders is imperative. This initial
installment of the four-part series, "Corneal Atlas," examines the pathophysiology, diagnosis, and management of infections of the cornea. Future articles will address corneal inflammations, trauma and degenerations.
The cornea has many innate defense systems that protect it from bacterial invasion. Corneal trauma, chronic eyelid disease, tear film abnormalities, systemic or iatrogenic immunosuppression, and hypoxic trauma from contact lens wear all threaten the cornea's defenses.1-6 When bacteria breach those defense systems and colonize and proliferate within the stroma, bacterial keratitis results. In the subsequent inflammatory reaction, polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs) accumulate to form an infiltrate. This reaction in the anterior segment and periorbital region will include lid edema, conjunctival and episcleral injection, and anterior chamber reaction with possible hypopyon formation.7-10
The clinical appearance of bacterial keratitis often varies with the virulence of the infective organism. Generally, gram-positive organisms produce a milder appearance, which may result in under-treatment; gram-negative organisms produce more dramatic presentations, and you would expect a greater degree of anterior segment involvement based upon a relatively small corneal lesion. In all cases, there will be a focal accumulation of inflammatory cells within the corneal stroma with an overlying excavation of the epithelium, referred to as a corneal ulcer. Anterior chamber inflammation is also invariably present, but varies depending upon organism's pathogenicity. Secondary uveitic response may be so severe that an inflammatory glaucoma may develop.
Treatment has historically employed fortified antibiotics, commonly gentamicin or tobramicin 1.5 percent combined with cefozalin.1,12 However, they are highly toxic and unstable. Currently, the fluorquinolones ofloxacin (Ocuflox) and ciprofloxacin (Ciloxan) provide excellent broad spectrum antibiotic coverage with minimal toxicity and are as effective at eradicating susceptible organisms as a fortified regimen.13-14 (See "The Role of Corticosteroids.")Acanthamoeba Keratitis The incidence of recognized Acanthamoeba keratitis, though still rare, is rising thanks to correct diagnosis and the increased use of confocal microscopy, which
readily identifies Acanthamoeba cysts in the cornea.20-21 Doctors rarely diagnose this chronic disease in its early stages because they often
mistake it for herpetic keratitis and bacterial keratitis. It can wax and wane for years before a doctor makes the correct diagnosis.20 In the response to certain
antibiotics and preservatives in topical medications, Acanthamoeba will encyst and become dormant, reducing symptoms and clinical signs.20 So it may appear
partially responsive to treatment and can assume a very chronic course prior to correct diagnosis. You should strongly suspect Acanthamoeba keratitis in chronic keratitis that does not respond to treatment.
Risk factors include corneal foreign body, contact with non-sterile water, bullous keratopathy, neurotrophic keratopathy, herpes simplex keratitis, radial keratotomy,
swimming and scuba diving, basement membrane dystrophy, contact lens wear and bacterial keratitis.18-22 Acanthamoeba keratitis can, however, develop without
identifiable risk factors.20 Anything that disrupts the corneal epithelium poses a risk.
Though it's historically associated with stromal ring infiltrate formation, only 6 percent of early Acanthamoeba keratitis cases and 16 percent of late cases present
this way.20 Most early cases present as non-descript epitheliopathy. However, limbitis occurs as the initial finding in 94 percent of early cases and 84 percent of
late cases.20-21 Another common, significant finding is radial keratoneuritis (perineuritis), irregularly thickened corneal nerves in the anterior to mid-stroma with
shaggy borders compared to normal nerves.21 Other clinical signs include irregular epithelial defect, corneal microcysts, punctate keratopathy, bullous keratopathy,
disciform stromal keratitis, anterior uveitis and a granulomatous stromal reaction.17,21 Acanthamoeba keratitis is often mistakenly treated for HSK. It can initially present
as a dendritic keratitis similar to HSK, but there are no herpetic terminal end bulbs in Acanthamoeba dendriform keratitis.20,22 HSK infections and Acanthamoeba keratitis do coexist22 where the latter presents
as a secondary opportunistic infection.22-23 The Acanthamoeba organism nestles in the thickened border of the epithelium.22 Consider Acanthamoeba infection in all
cases of presumed or actual HSK that don't respond to standard anti-viral therapy. Diagnosis is often difficult and is often made ex juvantia when all other treatments
fail. As with bacteria, corneal scrapings of Acanthamoeba may be cultured for diagnosis. However, the culture must use non-nutrient agar with overlay of either
Escherichia coli or Enterobacter. Culturing can take 1-9 days, or longer. Unfortunately, diagnostic yield is low and cultures are frequently negative despite the
presence of Acanthamoeba.20-21 Often, cultures reveal the presence of bacteria. This occurs as Acanthamoeba may be both incidental and opportunistic, and frequently coexists with bacterial colonies upon which it feeds. Acanthamoeba
frequently exists with other corneal diseases and may not be the primary or most active disease process in a combined keratitis.20 Confocal microscopy has provided a non-invasive, fast, accurate means of diagnosing Acanthamoeba
keratitis, but this technology is not widely available. Medications employed against Acanthamoeba include topical polyhexamethylene biguanide (PHMB), propamidine isethionate (Brolene), chlorhexidine digluconate
0.02 percent, polymixin B, neomycin and clortrimazole 1 percent.20-22,24 In one study of 10 patients, the combination of Brolene and PHMB successfully cured all
cases of Acanthamoeba keratitis. Cautious introduction of topical corticosteroids in association with anti-amoebic therapy expedited resolution of the inflammation and provided symptomatic relief.25 Fungal Keratitis Risk factors for filamentary fungal keratitis include ocular trauma (particularly if
organic vegetative matter is involved), antecedent topical corticosteroid therapy, and pre-existing ocular or systemic immu- nosuppressive diseases.5,27-31 Organic
trauma is most significant in initiating filamentary fungal keratitis, but yeast infection is mostly initiated by immunosuppression (through topical steroid use or systemic
disease) or alteration of normal epithelial barriers (persistent epithelial defects, neurotrophic keratitis, topical anesthetic use). Candida, an opportunist yeast, is part
of the normal human flora. Corneal defense system disruption can readily allow for this yeast infection.27 Once fungi begin colonization, their virulence determines their ability to proliferate
within the stroma and to penetrate into deeper layers beyond the reach of typical diagnostic and therapeutic measures. The hyphae make the organisms large
enough to preclude their complete ingestion by the host's inflammatory cells.27 Filamentary fungi initially produce a feathery, branching pattern in the cornea. The
cornea will appear a dull gray with possible heaping of epithelium and a dry, rough texture.32 There will typically be a plasmoid aqueous with hypopyon. Later, these
features are lost and fungal keratitis begins to resemble advanced bacterial keratitis. Subsequent misdiagnosis is likely. It is impossible to differentiate bacterial
keratitis from fungal keratitis on clinical judgment alone. Candida infection is more localized with a "button appearance," an expanding stromal infiltrate and a relatively small epithelial ulceration.27
Confirm your clinical suspicion of fungal keratitis either with cultures or corneal biopsy. Standard corneal scraping, with blood and chocolate agar incubated at
37°C for bacteria, is acceptable. However, inoculate additional blood and Sabouraud agar plates at room temperature.27 Anti-fungal sensitivity testing is
unreliable compared with antibiotic testing, and correlates poorly with clinical efficacy. Reserve corneal biopsy for cases in which your clinical suspicion is high for
fungal infection yet cultures were negative, or for when active ulceration persists despite aggressive antimicrobial therapy. Treating fungal keratitis is exceptionally frustrating. Most antifungal medications are
merely fungistatic and require an intact immune system as well as a prolonged course. Further, all antifungal medications except for natamycin must be adapted for
ophthalmic use from systemic antifungal medications. This results in an extreme ophthalmic toxicity. The incidence of fungal keratitis is low, so imminent advances in this area of ophthalmic medical therapy are unlikely.
Drug classes used to treat fungal keratitis include polyene antibiotics (nystatin, amphotericin B and natamycin), pyrimidine analogs (flucytosine), imidazoles (clortrimazole, miconozole, ketoconazole), triazoles (fluconazole and itraconazole) and silver sulfadiazine. Steroids are strictly contraindicated.27 (See Table 1, "Medical Therapy for Fungal Keratitis," above.)
Herpes simplex virus takes two forms: HSV type 1 (predominately oral) and HSV type 2 (predominately genital). Ocular HSV is primarily caused by HSV type 1 and is transmitted by direct contact or by exposure to secretions containing active virus cells.33 Ocular HSV presents as primary HSV, neonatal HSV, and recurrent HSV. More specific forms of recurrent HSV include epithelial infectious ulceration and trophic ulceration. (Next month, part two of this series will address other forms that represent stromal involvement.) Primary HSV infections typically occur before the age 5 and most commonly manifest as an upper respiratory illness. Vesicular skin and oral mucosa eruptions are uncommon. Rarely, the eye will be involved as a follicular conjunctivitis, non-descript epitheliopathy or ulcerative blepharitis. Infants may contact neonatal HSV during delivery, a form that is more commonly caused by HSV type 2. Ocular manifestation can include conjunctivitis, keratitis, stromal immune reaction, and cataract.33
HSV dendritic keratitis typically begins as an irregular, often linear epithelial disruption, which is easy to misdiagnose. The viral cells migrate from their latent resting area and actively replicate within the corneal epithelium. As the disease
HSV is largely unilateral; bilateral involvement occurs in only 2-7 percent of cases.33,36 If ulceration or edema encroaches upon the visual axis, vision will also be reduced. There may be a mild stromal haze beneath the dendritic ulcer. Typically, this is merely a diffusion of virus cell particles and not a stromal immune response. Most HSV dendritic ulcers are uncomplicated with only a mild stromal reaction that is limited to the anterior stroma and will spontaneously resolve within two weeks. Only after several occurrences will vision or globe integrity be severely threatened. Occasionally, these lesions will become more refractory or have more associated complications. In rare cases, the ulcer will enlarge to form a geographic ulcer. In some cases rather severe anterior uveitis can form.
These defects may persist for months and have the possibility of stromal melting and perforation and secondary opportunistic bacterial infection.33,35 Treatment of HSV dendritic keratitis involves topical antiviral medications such as vidarabine oint- ment (Vira-A) and trifluridine solution (Viroptic). Each medication is effective against HSV. However, trifluridine solution given nine times a day is currently the drug of choice in the United States due to its effectiveness and ease of use. Use it until its evident the ulcer is resolving, then taper rapidly. Should resolution not occur in 3-4 days, suspect clinical resistance and choose another antiviral medication. In Europe the drug of choice is topical acyclovir, which is as effective as trifluridine but does not have its high degree of local toxicity.37 Should concurrent anterior uveitis and ocular pain be present, add cycloplegic agents such as homatropine 5 percent or scopolamine 0.25 percent. Avoid topical corticosteroids when active epithelial HSV is present. Oral acyclovir 400mg five times per day offers specificity, potency and ocular penetration adequate to treat HSV keratitis, and is as effective as trifluridine.35 However, use oral therapy for HSV keratitis only if topical therapy is neither available nor practical. Oral acyclovir is advocated for use in the management of HSV anterior uveitis in patients receiving topical corticosteroids and trifluridine prophylaxis.38 Oral acyclovir does not assist, though, in preventing stromal keratitis or iritis in patients with HSV epithelial keratitis.39 To date, the most significant role of oral acyclovir is in its prophylactic ability, at 400mg PO BID, to reduce the recurrence of HSV dendritic keratitis.40 Treatment of trophic HSV ulcers involves healing the damaged basement membrane as well as the epithelium. Use copious irrigation at first, often with a bandage contact lens of high water content. Topical prophylactic antibiotics should also be employed. In cases of significant stromal inflammation, you may cautiously introduce low-potency topical corticosteroids with concurrent prophylactic topical antiviral medications.35
Varicella zoster virus (VZV), also known as herpes zoster virus (HZV), causes both varicella (chickenpox) and herpes zoster (shingles), and the recurrent ocular infection herpes zoster ophthalmicus (HZO).33 The virus gains access during primary infection to the sensory ganglia innervating select dermatomes. The thoracic nerves with corresponding dermatomes are the most frequently infected, followed by the cranial nerves. Of the cranial nerves, the trigeminal nerve is most frequently infected, with the ophthalmic division the most common site. Involvement of the nasociliary branch will give vesicular eruptions on the side of the nose (Hutchinson's sign) and an 85 percent likelihood that the eye will be involved. However, 61 percent of cases with eye involvement do not have Hutchinson's sign.41 Herpes zoster infection begins with a prodromal phase of flu-like illness followed within several days by neuralgia, which may be quite intense. Soon afterward there will be vesicular skin eruptions corresponding to the area of the affected dermatome. In trigeminal involvement, these eruptions will not cross the midline of the face.
Other corneal manifestations of HZV include endothelialitis, stromal infiltrates, disciform keratitis, and exposure keratitis.42 Corneal sensation is even more markedly reduced in HZV than HSV. As a result, neurotrophic keratitis, trophic ulcers and corneal melting with perforation are more significant concerns. Treatment of HZV epithelial keratitis involves systemic antiviral therapy, gentle debridement with a sterile cotton tip, and prophylactic topical antibiotics. Topical antiviral medications are ineffective. Acyclovir 800mg PO five times per day for 10 days is the traditional treatment for HZV.43 Famciclovir 500mg PO TID for seven days has recently become a more popular option due to an easier dosing schedule.33 Valacyclovir is another new, popular option. It is of utmost importance to begin oral antiviral therapy within 72 hours of skin eruptions. This reduces the incidence and severity of post-herpetic neuralgia.
Epidemic keratoconjunctivitis (EKC), caused by adenoviral serotypes 8, 19 and 37 is one of the more virulent adenoviral ocular infections.44-45 Modes of transmission include hand-shaking, finger-to-eye contact, medical instruments and waiting room chairs, among others.46 Ocular signs and symptoms include photophobia, ocular irritation, lid edema, preauricular adenopathy, follicular response, pseudomembrane formation, subconjunctival hemorrhage, serous discharge and corneal involvement. Corneal involvement in EKC manifests as a diffuse superficial punctate keratopathy, when active virus cells replicate within the epithelium. Subepithelial infiltrates eventually develop under areas of epitheliopathy as the immune system attempts to eradicate the organism. Should the visual axis become involved, acuity may fall precipitously.
A new medication in development heralds much promise. Cidofovir (Vistide) is an antiviral agent that has been used intravenously to treat cytomegalovirus retinitis. A topical form of this drug has been effective against adenoviruses that cause EKC, and has even shown activity against Epstein-Barr virus and herpes (simplex and zoster) virus. This drug should be commercially available in the near future. Thoroughly understanding the infectious threat to the cornea and the means available to respond to that threat is a crucial component of our optometric practice today. Next month, we'll look at how the cornea typically responds to infection, the corneal inflammatory response.
Dr. Sowka is an associate professor at Nova Southeastern University College of Optometry in Ft. Lauderdale, Fla., where he teaches the courses in glaucoma and retinal disease. Dr. Kabat is an
associate professor there where he is director of the college's externship program. They are co-authors of Review of Optometry's Handbook of Ocular Disease Management and are Contributing Editors for Review of Optometry.
1. Wong TY, Ng TP, Fong KSF, Tan DTHT. Risk factors and clinical outcomes between fungal and bacterial keratitis: A comparative study. CLAO 1997;23(4):275-281. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
Discussion of
bacterial keratitis management must address the use of topical corticosteroids. Many clinicians have avoided the use of these drugs when managing bacterial keratitis, as popular thinking dictated that their immunosuppressive
action would allow bacterial replication to progress unhindered and worsen the clinical course of the disease. Research clearly demonstrate that, in the presence of an effective antibiotic, the concurrent use of topical steroids
will not enhance bacterial replication and may, in fact, reduce scarring.15-16 We cannot overstate the potential benefits of corticosteroids. The inflammatory response in bacterial keratitis is as damaging to the corneal stroma
as is the infective organism itself. The polymorphonuclear leukocytes spill collagenolytic enzymes into the corneal stroma during the process of phagocytosis. If current antibiotic therapy can exogenously suppress the infectious
process, then secondary suppression of the detrimental unnecessary inflammatory response will speed resolution while minimizing corneal damage. However, to realize the maximum benefit from corticosteroids, you must institute this
therapy while the inflammatory infiltrate is still active. Waiting for complete re-epithelialization before instituting steroids negates their beneficial effects. Once complete re-epithelialization occurs, the infiltrate is already
inert. Clinically, we have found that corticosteroids are most effective when initiated 24 hours after the initiation of antibiotic therapy (with the cornea still openly ulcerated), as long as the ulcer has shown signs of
stabilization over this period. In our experience, this has led to increased patient comfort and faster resolution as compared with antibiotic-only regimens, and no ulcers worsening.6,10 |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
| | | | | | | |